TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn compared Costco and Sam’s Club across membership fees and rewards, return policies, credit cards, store brands, product availability, prices and food courts. Its writer found Costco had an edge on membership rewards and returns, while some other comparisons depended on product selection and the shopper’s priorities.
The Kitchn has published a comparison of Costco and Sam’s Club, examining membership fees, rewards, return policies, credit cards, store brands, product availability, prices and food courts. The report found that Costco costs slightly more for a standard membership but offers a higher potential annual reward at its top tier, while the writer favored Costco’s return process; the comparison is a reviewer’s assessment, not a controlled price study.
The report lists Costco’s Gold Star membership at $65 a year and its Executive membership at $130. Executive members can earn a 2% annual reward, capped at $1,250, according to the article. Sam’s Club’s Club membership is listed at $60 a year, and its Plus membership at $120, with a 2% Sam’s Cash reward capped at $750 annually. Sam’s Cash is redeemable at Sam’s Club, the report says, while Costco’s reward is described as cash. Sam’s Club may offer first-year membership discounts, and its free Guest Membership permits online shopping with a 10% surcharge, according to the source.
Both clubs provide two membership cards per household and advertise satisfaction guarantees for memberships and merchandise. The report says Costco generally accepts returns with a membership card, with exceptions and a 90-day return limit for major appliances. Sam’s Club prefers an original receipt, reserves the right to limit returns, and restricts some categories, including electronics and cell phones, to shorter return windows. The Kitchn writer judged Costco’s process easier, but individual eligibility and restrictions depend on the item and the retailer’s current policy.
The clubs’ co-branded credit cards offer different reward structures. The report lists Costco card rewards of 5% on gas at Costco, 4% on eligible gas and electric-vehicle charging up to $7,000 in annual purchases, 3% on restaurants and travel, 2% on Costco purchases and 1% on other purchases. For Sam’s Club’s Mastercard, it lists up to 5% back on gas for the first $6,000, then 1%; 3% on dining; and 1% on other purchases. Sam’s Club members also earn 1% Sam’s Cash on warehouse purchases, rising to 3% for Plus members. The article calls the card comparison a tie, but the value to a shopper depends on spending and membership tier.
How Fees and Returns Affect Value
The comparison matters to households choosing whether a warehouse-club membership will repay its annual cost. A $5 gap between the basic fees is small by itself, but rewards, return convenience and the products a household actually buys can shape the overall value. The higher stated reward cap at Costco’s Executive tier may appeal to high spenders, while Sam’s Club’s lower listed entry fee and periodic first-year discounts may be relevant to people trying the service.
These findings should not be treated as proof that one club is cheaper overall. The supplied report describes a reviewer’s research and experience, not a matched basket tested across locations and dates. Prices, promotions, inventory and policies can vary, so a shopper’s result may differ by region, purchase habits and which services they use.
Products Worth Considering
Ninja Mega Kitchen System Blender and Food Processor, 1500W, 72-oz Pitcher, 8-Cup Bowl, Black (BL770)
KitchenAid Compact 8-Cup Grain and Rice Cooker with Integrated Scale
Le Creuset Signature Deep Round Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 6.5 qt, Sea Salt
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
A Comparison Built From Club Research
The Kitchn report’s author, Patty Catalano, said she had been a Costco member for 14 years and had also belonged to Sam’s Club intermittently. For the comparison, she said she researched online, reviewed the clubs’ websites and app, and asked friends about their experiences. That background gives the article a personal-shopping perspective, while also meaning its category winners reflect the writer’s judgments.
The supplied source covers more than fees and returns: its comparison headings also include store brands, product availability, prices and food courts. The provided text cuts off during the store-brand discussion, however, so it does not establish a complete result or specific winner for those categories. The source also cautions that listed prices were accurate at the time of publication; the supplied material does not identify that date.
““All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.””
— The Kitchn
Prices and Policies May Change
The supplied material does not give the report’s publication date, current membership promotions, or a complete price-by-price comparison. It also ends before the article’s findings on store brands, product availability, prices and food courts are fully presented. Readers therefore cannot use this excerpt to confirm which club had lower prices or a better food-court offering overall.
Membership terms, rewards, card benefits and return rules may change, and some returns are subject to product-specific restrictions. The report’s findings should be checked against the clubs’ current terms before purchase; no independent, location-by-location price testing is described in the supplied source.
Check Current Local Club Terms
People comparing the clubs can check each retailer’s current membership page and return terms, then compare the prices of products they buy regularly at nearby locations. They should also account for their likely annual spending before weighing higher-tier rewards, and confirm any credit-card conditions directly with the card issuer. The source material does not identify a follow-up test or a scheduled update to the comparison.
Key Questions
Which club has the lower basic membership fee in the report?
The report lists Sam’s Club at $60 a year for Club membership and Costco at $65 for Gold Star. Those figures were accurate at the time the article was published, according to its disclaimer, but the source date was not included in the supplied material.
Which club has the higher stated top-tier reward cap?
The report lists Costco Executive’s 2% annual reward as capped at $1,250, compared with a $750 annual cap for Sam’s Club Plus’s 2% Sam’s Cash. Sam’s Cash can be spent at Sam’s Club, according to the article; rewards and terms may be subject to current program rules.
Does the report say Costco has a better return policy?
The writer favored Costco because most returns can be made with a membership card and without an original receipt. The article also describes exceptions, including a 90-day limit for major appliances, and says Sam’s Club may limit returns and applies shorter windows to some categories. Check current terms for the specific item.
Does the supplied comparison establish which store has lower prices?
No. The source says the article compared prices, but the supplied text does not include its price findings or a complete matched-basket test. It also warns that prices were accurate only at the time of publication.
Source: thekitchn.com
