TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A VinePair report says an Aug. 17 Instagram video featuring bartender Kate Gerwin criticizing some guest-shift events drew 285,000 views and 782 comments as of the report’s publication. Gerwin said her criticism focused on events she believes serve awards-chasing and sponsorship interests, while critics pointed to her own history of guest shifts. The motives behind individual events and the wider claims about awards influence remain disputed.
A video of bartender Kate Gerwin criticizing some guest shifts drew unusually high engagement after it was posted to Instagram on Aug. 17, according to VinePair. The remarks prompted support and accusations of hypocrisy, turning a debate about bar events into a wider dispute over awards, brand sponsorship and industry priorities.
The video appeared in Hospitality Hot Takes, an Instagram series by Los Angeles-based bartender and creator Saeed “Hawk” House. In the nearly three-minute interview, Gerwin argued that some guest shifts are staged to pursue awards recognition or bring industry friends together, rather than serve a bar’s regular customers. She also said brands should direct money toward retaining employees instead of funding such events. At one point, she said, “I wanna see ‘em go away.”
VinePair reported that the post had received 285,000 views, 12,200 likes and 782 comments at the time of writing. The outlet said those were the highest counts in each category for House’s series; its videos averaged about 13,000 views per day, while its most popular posts typically received 1,000 to 2,000 likes and 100 to 200 comments. These figures describe the post’s performance as reported then, not current totals.
House said he expected the conversation to be heated, in part because Gerwin had taken part in many guest shifts. Gerwin said she had not expected the video to go viral and suggested the speaker’s gender may have affected the response. Some commenters supported her position; others argued that her own participation made her criticism hypocritical. Gerwin said she knows her experience and personal benefits make her a target for that charge.
The Debate Over Guest-Shift Priorities
The argument matters to bartenders, bar owners and sponsors because guest shifts can involve staff time, promotional spending and access to influential industry figures. Gerwin’s account raises questions about who benefits from these events: visiting bartenders and host venues, regular customers, brands, or people connected to awards judging. The report does not establish how common any one purpose is.
Gerwin specifically criticized events she believes are organized to court people associated with The 50, formerly known as World’s 50 Best Bars. She alleged that some venues hold shifts when a voter is present and rely on brand sponsorship to pay for them. She said brands may be funding events while cutting other jobs, including brand ambassador roles. These are Gerwin’s claims and interpretation; the report does not independently document the events’ finances or establish that sponsorship affects award voting.
The viral response also illustrates how a short, sharply worded interview can compress a more specific argument into a yes-or-no question about an entire practice. Gerwin later said her objection was not to guest shifts in principle, but to what she views as the purpose behind some prominent events.
professional bartender cocktail shaker set
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Gerwin’s Experience and Awards Critique
Gerwin owns Happy Accidents in Albuquerque and was preparing to open Bad Apple in Houston, according to VinePair. The outlet described her as an influential figure in the bar industry with a long record of participating in guest shifts around the world. She said those experiences gave her a view of how some events are organized and why she objects to their connection with awards attention.
House told VinePair that Gerwin’s profile helped make the clip resonate: she had participated in many guest shifts, the very practice she was criticizing. Gerwin offered another possible explanation, saying she believed a male industry figure had previously made a dismissive public comment about World’s 50 Best without receiving the same response. That comparison is her assessment of the reaction, not a demonstrated explanation for the video’s reach.
The interview was part of a series designed to present concise, provocative opinions about the hospitality industry. Gerwin told VinePair she had not fully watched the finished edit and thought the fast reactions to hot takes could obscure the point she intended to make. She said she hoped the underlying criticism would become clearer as the response cooled.
““The moment I filmed it, I knew it was going to be a little hot. But I wasn’t prepared for what was to come after it was posted.””
— Saeed “Hawk” House, speaking to VinePair
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Claims Still Under Dispute
The report does not independently verify Gerwin’s claims about venues seeking favor with awards voters, the presence of voters at particular guest shifts, or the effects of sponsorship on award outcomes. It also provides no financial data comparing event spending with staffing cuts, and no response from The 50 or the brands mentioned in Gerwin’s broader criticism.
It remains unclear how many guest shifts fit the pattern she described, how the Instagram post’s engagement changed after VinePair published its figures, and whether the debate will affect how venues or sponsors plan future events. The report records opposing reactions but does not quantify the balance of support and criticism.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Whether the Industry Responds
Gerwin told VinePair she hoped people would understand that her criticism targeted the purpose behind some events, rather than guest shifts as a whole. The immediate next step is whether bar operators, sponsors and people involved in cocktail awards address the questions raised about event costs, voter access and judging practices. The source material does not report any formal response or policy change.
For now, the dispute remains a public argument shaped by the original video, Gerwin’s explanation and viewers’ reactions. Further reporting or statements from the awards organization, participating venues and sponsors would be needed to establish whether the practices she described are widespread.
bartender training and certification books
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
What did Kate Gerwin say about guest shifts?
In an Instagram interview, Gerwin criticized some guest shifts as events driven by awards ambitions or industry networking. She also argued that brands should spend more on retaining staff and said those events can alienate regular customers.
Why did the video attract so much attention?
VinePair reported 285,000 views, 12,200 likes and 782 comments at the time of publication. House said Gerwin’s prominence and her record of participating in guest shifts helped make the remarks especially contentious.
Why did some people call Gerwin hypocritical?
Commenters pointed to her history of taking part in guest shifts while criticizing the practice. Gerwin acknowledged that record and said it gave her firsthand knowledge, while also recognizing that she had benefited from the events.
Did the report prove that guest shifts affect awards voting?
No. Gerwin alleged that some bars use events to gain favor with people connected to The 50’s judging collective. The report did not independently verify that claim or establish that guest shifts influence voting outcomes.
Source: rss
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
